An examination of the paradigm of catastrophism in geology in principles of geology by charles lyell
Scotland and Her Universities in the Nineteenth Century, 2nd ed. Google Scholar Wilson, L.
Theory of catastrophism was proposed by
Scientists vigorously rejected Velikovsky's conjectures. Google Scholar Hooykaas, R. He added extensive editorial notes to the translation, explicitly linking the latest of Cuvier's revolutions with the biblical flood. The geologist Charles Lyell built upon Hutton's ideas during the first half of 19th century and amassed observations in support of the uniformitarian idea that the Earth's features had been shaped by same geological processes that could be observed in the present acting gradually over an immense period of time. On their first stop ashore at St Jago , Darwin found rock formations which -seen "through Lyell's eyes"- gave him a revolutionary insight into the geological history of the island, an insight he applied throughout his travels. While he did speculate that the catastrophe responsible for the most recent extinctions in Eurasia might have been the result of the inundation of low-lying areas by the sea, he did not make any reference to Noah's flood. Google Scholar Hugget, R. Google Scholar Gillispie, C. The main argument against Lyell is that he took an a priori approach in his work. Google Scholar Watson, R. One opponent of Principles of Geology that agreed with this point was Adam Sedgwick. Google Scholar Suppe, F. The first rule is that geologic change comes from slow and continual procedures that have been happening over a long period of time. Google Scholar Sober, E.
Google Scholar Grave, S. Google Scholar Newton, I. Press, Cambridge MA. Google Scholar Hugget, R.
Google Scholar Olson R. This led him to believe the Earth was several million years old. He speculated that the planet Venus is a former " comet " which was ejected from Jupiter and subsequently 3, years ago made two catastrophic close passes by Earth, 52 years apart, and later interacted with Mars, which then had a series of near collisions with Earth which ended in BCE, before settling into its current orbit. I believe that the only way to understand Lyell's role in the history of science is to maintain the unity of his synthesis. I will conclude with an analysis of the methodological function of principles in Lyell's scientific endeavour. Google Scholar Stewart, D. On their first stop ashore at St Jago , Darwin found rock formations which -seen "through Lyell's eyes"- gave him a revolutionary insight into the geological history of the island, an insight he applied throughout his travels. He frequently cited Cuvier's work, even though Cuvier had proposed an inundation of limited geographic extent and extended duration, whereas Buckland, to be consistent with the biblical account, was advocating a universal flood of short duration. Motte, repr. He added extensive editorial notes to the translation, explicitly linking the latest of Cuvier's revolutions with the biblical flood. Jameson translated Cuvier's introduction into English, publishing it under the title Theory of the Earth. Google Scholar Hooykaas, R. Today most geologists combine catastrophist and uniformitarianist standpoints, taking the view that Earth's history is a slow, gradual story punctuated by occasional natural catastrophic events that have affected Earth and its inhabitants. One opponent of Principles of Geology that agreed with this point was Adam Sedgwick. Google Scholar Rudwick, M.
Google Scholar Suppe, F. This paper suggested that a 10 kilometres 6. May 9th edition1 vol.
May 5th edition, 4 vols. Some of the theories about Catastrophism in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries were connected with religion and catastrophic origins were sometimes considered miraculous rather than natural events.
Google Scholar Copyright information. Download preview PDF.
Uniformitarianism vs catastrophism worksheet
Newton's Metaphysics of Nature, Kluwer A. Vol 1 - Vol 2 - Vol 3 - Vol 4 6th edition, 3 vols. Google Scholar Whewell, W. Since then, the debate about the extinction of the dinosaurs and other mass extinction events has centered on whether the extinction mechanism was the asteroid impact, widespread volcanism which occurred about the same time , or some other mechanism or combination. The criticism of Lyell and his work continued into the 20th century. Google Scholar Mamiani, M. Even if catastrophes are rare, their magnitude may affect geology more than has been appreciated under Lyell's version of uniformitarianism.
Google Scholar Quine, W.
based on 78 review